Supernumerary teeth, also known as hyperdontia, are additional teeth that develop beyond the normal count of 32 and can occur in the maxilla, mandible, or both, manifesting as either single or multiple extra teeth, and may be unilateral or bilateral. This case report presents a rare occurrence of multiple impacted supernumerary teeth in a non-syndromic patient, featuring two supernumerary teeth adjacent to an impacted mandibular third molar, an impacted supernumerary mandibular premolar, and an impacted maxillary distomolar. This unique combination emphasizes the variability in supernumerary tooth development and the need for thorough diagnostic assessment and precise treatment planning.